Roof Repair or Replace Calculator
Enter the material, age, damaged share and the repair quote. Three common rules of thumb give a clear lean.

The replacement price starts at a typical planning number. Use a real quote if you have one.
- The 30 percent rule
- Quote against replacement
- Age against expected life
- Quote vs replacement
- 0%
- Roof damaged
- 0%
- Expected years left
- 0
Rules of thumb, not an inspection. A written estimate from a company in the Top 10 lists gives you real numbers.
Three rules of thumb
Three simple rules of thumb help with the repair or replace question. The 30 percent rule says to consider replacing when more than about a third of the roof is damaged or worn. The quote rule compares the repair quote with the cost of a new roof, and a repair that costs a quarter or more of a replacement is hard to justify on an old roof. And a roof in the last fifth of its expected life is a poor place to put money.
The tool counts how many rules point to replacement. None means repair, one leans repair, two lean replace and three says replace. It is a way to start the conversation, not a verdict. A written estimate from a company in the Top 10 lists will give you the real numbers.
Get real estimates
Compare written estimates from two or three companies before you decide.